Skip to main content

Minutes, 29 October 1835

  1. Home > 
  2. The Papers > 

Minutes, 29 October 1835

Source Note

Kirtland high council, Minutes, , Geauga Co., OH, 29 Oct. 1835. Featured version copied [between ca. 4 Apr. and ca. 16 May 1836] in Minute Book 1, pp. 127–129; handwriting of ; CHL. For more complete source information, see the source note for Minute Book 1.

Historical Introduction

In October 1835, the high council met to discuss allegations that , a member of the Quorum of the , and his wife, Mary Cahoon Elliott, had abused their teenage daughter by beating and whipping her. According to one of the witnesses who testified at the meeting, the Elliott affair had provoked public discussion in the small village of , Ohio. On 29 October, the high council met to depose witnesses and determine if the Elliotts’ actions merited official church discipline.
The complaint, instigated by , likely involved the couple’s treatment of Lucena, ’s eldest child from a previous marriage. Elliott and William Smith had been acquainted for several years prior to the accusation. Both men marched to as part of the in May 1834, and both were ordained as leaders in the church’s governing bodies in February 1835. No extant records indicate how William Smith became aware of the alleged abuse within the Elliott family.
The trial unfolded in two sessions. The opening session seems to have focused on ’s allegations against David Elliott. Five witnesses, including JS, were deposed during the first trial; JS testified in favor of the defendant. As the minutes indicate, the council ultimately ruled that although “the complaint was not without foundation,” the charge of abuse “had not been fully sustained.” The council reconvened later that evening to hear William Smith’s charges against Mary Elliott. During this hearing, a “Sister Childs,” who testified she lived in the Elliott household, was introduced as a witness. JS’s journal indicates that in contrast to the first hearing, in which he was called to testify, JS was asked to “take a seat with the presidency and preside” over the second session.
An account in JS’s journal suggests that the second session was contentious. Six members of the council, rather than the usual four, were appointed to speak during the evening session, which according to established protocol meant that the case was deemed difficult. During the meeting, JS and engaged in a heated exchange that opened up an unpleasant rift between the two brothers. At the conclusion of the second session, both Mary and confessed their wrongs before the council, pledged to correct their behavior, and were forgiven.

Footnotes

  1. [1]

    David Elliott joined the church in upstate New York in early 1831 and married Mary Cahoon on 21 May 1831 in Kirtland, Ohio. The couple eventually settled in Chagrin, Ohio. Though Elliott was commanded to move to Jackson County, Missouri, in a 31 August 1831 revelation, he appears to have remained in Chagrin. (Revelation, 31 Aug. 1831; Letter from Oliver Cowdery, 28 Jan. 1832; Letter to Church Leaders in Jackson County, MO, 21 Apr. 1833.)

  2. [2]

    Chagrin was officially renamed Willoughby sometime in late 1834 or early 1835, following the establishment of Willoughby Medical College. However, JS and other church members often referred to the town as Chagrin.

  3. [3]

    Little is known about the Elliott family. Family genealogical records suggest that Mary Cahoon was David Elliott’s third wife. According to these records, he married Almira Holliday in 1821, and in the following year Almira gave birth to Lucena. He later married Margery Quick in 1823. Mary Cahoon was therefore Lucena’s stepmother. (“History Written by David Elliott,” attached to “David Elliott, 1799–1855,” 27 Nov. 2014, FamilySearch; “Elliott, David,” born 18 Nov. 1799, submitted by Alvin E. Morris, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, Family Group Records Collection; Archives Section, 1942–1969, microfilm 1,274,009, U.S. and Canada Record Collection, FHL.)

    U.S. and Canada Record Collection. FHL.

  4. [4]

    William Smith was chosen to be a member of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles on 14 February 1835; Elliott was called as a member of the Quorum of the Seventy on 28 February 1835. (Minutes, Discourse, and Blessings, 14–15 Feb. 1835; Minutes and Blessings, 28 Feb.–1 Mar. 1835.)

  5. [5]

    JS, Journal, 29 Oct. 1835.

  6. [6]

    See Revised Minutes, 18–19 Feb. 1834 [D&C 102].

  7. [7]

    JS, Journal, 29 Oct. 1835.

Asterisk (*) denotes a "featured" version, which includes an introduction and annotation.
*Minutes, 29 October 1835
Minute Book 1

Page 127

Go to next page 2
Oct. 29th 1835
This day a High Council was called at ’s for the purpose of trying certain cases.
Names of the counsellors present
After the council had taken their seats according to their respective numbers President opened the council by prayer.
A charge was read against & wife preferred by Elder for abusing their daughter by beating and whipping her. Two counsellors on each side were appointed to speak. (Viz.) and on one side and on the other & . Witnesses on part of the were & his wife Roxana.
testified that said ’s girl came to his house and complained that her father had abused her, and whipped her & that some marks were found upon her arms, body &c. when she had been whipped. This circumstance took place about ten days since, The girl was about fifteen years old, and that she said she would, or had a mind to make away with herself, hang herself, or something of the kind to get rid of her trouble and affliction. The testimony of Roxana Lyons, that was that Mrs. Elliott threatned to take the broomstick and kill her, and also confirmed the testimony of her husband.
Sister Osgood testifies, that some three years since she (sister Osgood) lived at said ’s and that [p. 127]
View entire transcript

|

Cite this page

Source Note

Document Transcript

Page 127

Go to next page 2

Document Information

Related Case Documents
Editorial Title
Minutes, 29 October 1835
ID #
8742
Total Pages
3
Print Volume Location
JSP, D5:26–29
Handwriting on This Page
  • Warren A. Cowdery
Go to page