The “Historian’s Office, Martyrdom Account, Draft,” and the “Historian’s Office, Martyrdom Account” are the two complete, extant iterations of efforts by later church historians to record the murder of JS and , including the events leading up to their deaths and the immediate aftermath. As stated at the beginning of both accounts, the information was compiled from a number of different sources, including other journals, letters, and various other documents. It was put into a cohesive narrative during the 1850s by Church Historian’s Office clerks , Jonathan Grimshaw, and , presumably under the direction of the church historian, .
was the initial scribe for approximately the first half of “Historian’s Office, Martyrdom Account, Draft,” and Grimshaw was the primary scribe for the remainder. Sometimes slips of paper were attached to pages of the draft with additional or alternative text to be included with a specific page. Page 12 of the draft has a notation by Grimshaw indicating that previously drafted text was to be added to the draft; instead of copying the text, he simply inserted a whole leaf into the draft. This leaf, in ’s handwriting, contains various numbered vignettes. It appears to be part of a larger collection of vignettes, as it is paginated “5” and “6,” and is likely the surviving portion of an earlier iteration of the martyrdom account by Thomas Bullock. The remainder of Bullock’s effort is not extant.
“Historian’s Office, Martyrdom Account,” which is a more final copy written primarily by Grimshaw in the mid-1850s, similarly has slips of papers attached. It also includes several leaves that were physically removed from “Martyrdom Account, Draft”; these leaves were renumbered to match the pagination of the copy: pages 7–10 in the draft became pages 11–14 in the more final copy; pages 13–14 became 19–20; most extensively, pages 19–52 became 27–60; and finally, page 57, the last page of the draft, became page 73 in the new version. Although these leaves are cataloged with the more final copy, this website presents the pages both in the draft, as originally paginated, and in the more final copy, with the new pagination. Two additional items were added at the end of the more final copy. A bifolium paginated as “75” and “2” and written on the back of a printed Utah Territory legal form gives an account of the arrival of the bodies of JS and Hyrum Smith in Nauvoo as well as the funeral and burial. It was written by Grimshaw and edited by from information given by . On the final leaf, which is torn and is paginated “76,” Bullock drafted an introduction to a passage from ’s History of Illinois, with instructions to include the passage from Ford’s history in the martyrdom account.
Both the draft and the more final copy were edited by , Grimshaw, and . It is not clear when the edits were made. The more final copy of the account appears to be what was used in 1856 when the final version was copied into the last volume of the Joseph Smith’s multivolume manuscript history (JS History, vol. F-1, 147, 151–204).
Page [16]
following is a copy “State” (see T. & S. <marble> 562) ”L. S”, and insisted that they should <then> go to Jail. Joseph demanded a copy of the , which was <then> refused <but afterward given.>. Mess<rs> and , as Counsel, insisted that the prisoners were entitled to be brought before the <a> justice <of the Peace> for examination, before they could be sent to jail. The to their surprise <then> exhibited the <following> mittimus <-[see T & S 562— marble.]->
we <Joseph> remonstrated <against such barefaced; illegal, and tyrannical proceedings>, and <but> the < still insisted they should go to jail.> urged. requested the to wait until he could see , and was told by Bettersworth <> that he would <only> wait 5 minutes. We <Joseph and again> remonstrated, and he waited until about 9 o’clock: when we <they> heard by that the did not think it within the sphere of his duty to interfere, as they were in the hands of the civil power <law,> and therefore he had <not the power to stay process> <(or <the> due course of law, and that he cd. not interrupt a civil officer in the discharge of his duty.>
<see Note A. page 16a> Joseph, , and tried to get past the guard; but they all failed,and as he <> went to the door, he met with some 20 men to guard the prisoners to jail. He accompanied to <(Captn.)> Justice R. F. Smith, who gave as a cause for issuing the warrant of committal, that the prisoners were not personally safe at the hotel. then requested the to have a company < of troops from some other county> detailed to guard the jail [p. [16]]