The Papers
Reference
About
Journal, December 1841–December 1842
Source Note
Source Note
JS, Journal, Dec. 1841–Dec. 1842; handwriting of , , , and ; signatures of and ; 90 pages; in “The Book of the Law of the Lord,” Record Book, 1841–1845, CHL. Includes shorthand; also includes redactions and use marks.
JS’s journal for December 1841–December 1842 was inscribed in a large, leather-bound blank book made with thick paper. The paper bears a star-shaped watermark in the middle of each leaf and was printed with forty-seven blue lines on each side. The text block was originally formed with thirty gatherings of eight leaves each. The second gathering, however, has only six leaves. This six-leaf gathering was either a binding error or one sheet came loose from the binding before the book was inscribed (the book’s inscription and pagination runs through this gathering without skipping any text or page numbers). The gatherings were sewn all along. Each set of front and back endpapers consisted of a gathering of four leaves of unlined paper, but only two leaves are now extant in the back gathering. The trimmed pages measure 16¼ × 10½ inches (41 × 27 cm). Headbands were sewn onto the text block. The exterior pages of the endpapers are joined to the pasteboards with a strip of pink cloth. Marbled papers featuring a shell pattern with green body and veins of red and yellow are glued to the inside covers of the boards and to the exterior page of each gathering of endpapers. The leaf edges are stained green. The text block is bound in a ledger style to the boards. The spine was constructed with four false raised bands demarcating five panels. The boards and spine are covered in suede leather with additional leather strips over the top and bottom of the book. The suede leather was blind tooled on the outside covers, the raised bands of the spine, and the turned-in edges on the inside cover. The additional leather strips, which also cover the first and fifth panels of the spine, are embossed with dual lines and vegetal designs along the borders and have gold line filling. The spine is further embossed with the number “6” in 20-point type on the fifth panel. The second and fourth panels have black-painted squares of paper glued to them. These feature gold lining and decoration at the top and bottom. The completed volume measures 17 × 11 × 2¼ inches (43 × 28 × 6 cm) and includes 244 free leaves. A penciled inscription at the inside top corner of page [ii]—the verso of the front marbled flyleaf—gives what appears to be an expensive price for this high-quality blank book: “bth | 10.00”.
inscribed nine revelations in the book on the first twenty-three pages of lined paper. made minor revisions to these revelation texts. Apparently either Richards or Thompson inscribed page numbers on pages 3–18, beginning at the first page of lined paper, in a stylized script. Richards inscribed page numbers on pages 19–25 as well as on the next several dozen pages—which included journal entries for JS and records of donations in cash and in kind for the construction of the . At some point page [1], the recto of the last leaf of unlined endpaper in the front of the book, was inscribed with a title: “THE | BOOK | of the | LAW | of the | LORD”. Because these words are hand lettered in various ornate styles, the handwriting cannot be identified. A matching title appears on the spine of the volume: the square label of black paper on the second panel of the spine bears a smaller square label of white paper with a hand-lettered inscription: “LAW | — of the — | LORD.” Willard Richards inscribed pages 26–126 of the book, with help from on pages 27–28 and 72–87. Clayton inscribed the rest of the volume, pages 127–477, with help from on pages 168–171 and from on pages 189–190 and 192–201. These clerks and scribes generally paginated the book and inscribed dateline page headers along the way as they inscribed its texts.
The donation records constitute the bulk of the volume. The journal entries are inscribed on pages 26, 31, 33, 36, 39, 43, 44, 48, 56–61, 66–67, 88–95, 122–135, and 164–215. As is also the case with the pages bearing donation records, many of the pages bearing journal entries have vertical margin lines inscribed in graphite. The journal entries themselves are inscribed in ink that is now brown. Pages 165–181, however, either include or are entirely in blue ink. Some of the entries begin with a descriptive heading as well as a dateline. The entry for 6 January 1842, for example, features the large heading “The New Year”. Page 58 features the large double underlined heading “Journal of President Joseph”. Many of the entries are divided by horizontal lines. Where groups of journal entries span several pages, notes written at the beginning and end of these spans reference the previous or succeeding pages of journal entries. At various stages in the production of the volume, and signed their names to their work (pages 126, 181, 215).
The volume contains a number of redactions that were made as the journal entries were later revised for inclusion in the “History of Joseph Smith” published in Mormon newspapers in the mid-nineteenth century. Most of these redactions, made in graphite, were subsequently erased. The upper left-hand corner of page 3 bears the graphite inscription “6”, a redactive note on page 43 is inscribed in purple pencil, and red-penciled “X”s appear in the margins next to entries on pages 164 and 180. Notes written on three white and three blue slips of paper of various sizes have been inserted in various places, as well as a clipped portion of a -era elder’s certificate form with no notes (apparently just a placeholder). There are also two leaves of pink paper just inside the front of the volume. All of these slips and leaves of paper are loose and appear to have been added to the book subsequent to its use as a journal.
The book is intricately related to its successor volume, the 1844–1846 donation record, and to a volume that indexed the donation records. The “Law of the Lord” is listed as such in inventories of church records made in Salt Lake City, Utah, in the 1850s. These show that the volume was held for a time in the office of church president Brigham Young. In 1880, , president of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles, carried the book to a stake Relief Society conference in Salt Lake City. At some point the book was marked on the spine with an archival sticker, which was later removed. The book eventually was housed with the papers of Joseph Fielding Smith, apparently during his tenure as church historian and recorder (1921–1970), and then became part of the First Presidency’s papers when he became church president in 1970. In 2010, the First Presidency gave custody of the book to the Church History Library. This evidence indicates continuous institutional custody and authenticity.
Footnotes
- [1]
The page numbers on pages 19–71, 86–90, and 122–125 are in the handwriting of Willard Richards; on pages 72–85, 91–121, 126–167, and 171–477, in the handwriting of William Clayton; and on pages 168–170, in the handwriting of Erastus Derby. There are two pages numbered 453. Pages 476–477 constitute the last leaf of lined paper. The headers generally consist of a year or a month and year. The headers inscribed on pages 26–27, 29–71, 88–95, 119, and 121–126 are in the handwriting of Richards; the headers inscribed on pages 28, 72–87, 96–118, 120, 127–167, and 172–215 are in the handwriting of Clayton; pages 168–171, which were inscribed by Derby, have no headers. A few other pages are missing headers.
- [2]
- [3]
This serialized history drew on the journals herein, beginning with the 4 July 1855 issue of the Deseret News and with the 3 January 1857 issue of the LDS Millennial Star.
- [4]
Most of these now-erased graphite inscriptions are recoverable with bright white light and magnification. Pages 209–215, which were not erased, represent the state of the journal entries generally when they were used for drafting the “History of Joseph Smith.”
- [5]
Tithing and Donation Record, 1844–1846, CHL; Trustee-in-trust, Index and Accounts, 1841–1847, CHL.
Trustee-in-Trust. Index and Accounts, 1841–1847. CHL.
- [6]
Historian’s Office, “Inventory. Historian’s Office. 4th April 1855,” [1]; Historian’s Office, “Inventory. Historians Office. G. S. L. City April 1. 1857,” [1]; Historian’s Office, “Historian’s Office Inventory G. S. L. City March 19. 1858,” [1]; Historian’s Office, “Historian’s Office Catalogue Book March 1858,” [11], Historian’s Office, Catalogs and Inventories, 1846–1904, CHL.
Historian’s Office. Catalogs and Inventories, 1846–1904. CHL. CR 100 130.
- [7]
Emmeline B. Wells, “Salt Lake Stake Relief Society Conference,” Woman’s Exponent, 1 July 1880, 9:22.
Woman’s Exponent. Salt Lake City. 1872–1914.
- [8]
“Inventory of President Joseph Fielding Smith’s Safe,” 23 May 1970, First Presidency, General Administration Files, CHL.
“Inventory of President Joseph Fielding Smith’s Safe,” 23 May 1970. First Presidency, General Administration Files, 1921–1972. CHL.
- [9]
Letter of transfer, Salt Lake City, UT, 8 Jan. 2010, CHL.
Letter of Transfer, Salt Lake City, UT, 8 Jan. 2010. CHL.
Historical Introduction
Historical Introduction
, , , and recorded JS’s journal entries from 13 December 1841 through 20 December 1842 in a large leather-bound blank book. The book was first used by church recorder to copy revelations. Between January 1841 and his death on 27 August the same year, Thompson recorded nine of JS’s revelations, beginning with the 19 January 1841 revelation commanding the building of the , Illinois, and a boardinghouse called the . On 11 December 1841, following his election as “sole Trustee in Trust for the Church” earlier in the year, JS instructed that all donations for building the Nauvoo temple be received directly through his office rather than through the committee overseeing construction of the temple. Two days later, he appointed Willard Richards of the Quorum of the Twelve Apostles as recorder for the temple and as his personal scribe. Richards then became custodian of the book Thompson had used for recording revelations, and Richards apparently began recording journal entries and tithing donations in some manner on that same day. However, the quality of inscription for the journal entries in the book suggests that they are copies of previously inscribed notes, and if Richards began making such notes in mid-December it is less certain when he began copying them into the book. The book apparently was kept in the “counting room” on the lower floor of on Water Street, where Richards received and entered donations and also inscribed JS’s journal.
Journal entries and donations were kept concurrently in the book, alternating sometimes every other page and chronologically leapfrogging each other. This pattern was especially pronounced near the beginning of the book, where donations and journal entries occasionally appear together on a single page. Over time, however, larger and larger blocks of text were dedicated to either donations or journal entries until eventually, in December 1842, the journal was transferred to another book. This slow separation or disentanglement of the journal and donation records—the reasons for which are unclear—was completed long before the volume was filled; indeed, only 90 of the volume’s 478 pages include journal entries, and all of these are within the first 215 pages. In several places it is clear that lists of donations were recorded earlier than were the journal entries found on preceding pages; that is, Richards and William Clayton—who was assigned to assist in the recorder’s office 10 February 1842—left several pages blank between lists of donations and then later filled in those pages with journal entries. This practice sometimes left the scribes with insufficient space to finish a journal entry before running into the list of donations, requiring them to continue the entry several pages later.
The interspersing of journal entries with pages of donation records, as well as JS’s conscious efforts to record the names of people who helped him, suggests that the volume as a whole was understood in terms of an 1832 revelation that “a hystory and a general church reccord” must be kept “of all things that transpire in Zion and of all those who consecrate properties . . . and also there manner of life and the[ir] faith and works.” This record was to be kept in a book called “the book of the Law of God”—a book whose name parallels that of “the book of the law of the Lord” mentioned in the Old Testament. continued the pagination of ’s revelation transcripts and, at some point in time, the title “The Book of the Law of the Lord” was inscribed in the front of the book Richards was filling with journal entries and donation records. That the revelation transcripts, donation records, and journal entries appear under the same title and pagination suggests the book’s creators understood its title to comprehend all of its parts.
During the first few months of keeping JS’s journal, included events that occurred before his appointment as JS’s scribe and temple recorder as well as current journal entries. For example, in his 13 December 1841 entry on deteriorating conditions in , Illinois, Richards explained what led church members to settle there in the first place. At times these retrospective entries eclipse the events of the day on which they were written and have no apparent connection to surrounding entries. The entries for 17 and 29 December 1841, for example, relate to ’s July 1841 arrival at following his mission to England and to the October 1841 laying of the cornerstone for the , respectively, but they record nothing about the events of 17 and 29 December. Multiple entries for individual days, sometimes separated by several pages, add to the complexity of the first part of the journal and also suggest that Richards wrote retrospectively at least part of the time. Only after Richards moved into the Smith home in mid-January 1842 and was able to more closely observe JS’s actions did the entries become more regular, and even then multiple entries occasionally occurred. Immediately preceding the entry for 15 January 1842, the header “Journal of President Joseph” appears—showing that by the time he moved into JS’s home, Richards considered the daily entries he was keeping as journal entries.
kept JS’s journal in the Book of the Law of the Lord through 29 June 1842, shortly after which he left for , Massachusetts, to bring his family to . Among the numerous topics addressed in Richards’s entries are problems relating to the purchase of land in the Nauvoo area, the organization of the Female Relief Society, and the developing rift between JS and two of his close associates, and . When Richards left for , he transferred the book—and therefore JS’s journal—to his assistant, , to keep during his absence. Two months later, in early September, Clayton was appointed temple recorder, officially replacing Richards as custodian of the Book of the Law of the Lord. Some of Clayton’s entries include accounts of JS’s activities during the day as well as his activities later in the evening. In some of these entries, the record of the evening events is inscribed in an ink that differs from the ink he used to record JS’s activities earlier in the day yet matches that of the following day’s entry. This indicates that he was probably writing in the book about some events the very day they occurred.
’s first entry (30 June 1842) retrospectively records three events dealing with the —the dedication of the baptismal font on 8 November 1841, a miraculous healing in the waters of the font in February 1842, and a deposit made in the cornerstone on 25 September 1841. JS may have directed the inclusion of this material after having “heard the Recorder [] Read in the Law of the Lord” the day before; alternatively, Clayton may have recorded it on his own in his role as assistant temple recorder. Either way, its inclusion clearly demonstrates the desire to include information about the temple in the record. The Book of the Law of the Lord was to be kept in the temple when it was completed.
had kept JS’s journal for little more than a month when, on 8 August 1842, JS was arrested as part of an effort to extradite him to to stand trial for alleged complicity in the attempted assassination of former Missouri governor . JS’s subsequent efforts to avoid extradition to Missouri were attended by a flurry of letter writing among JS, his associates, and governor . , a private teacher living in the Smith home, and , who also had clerical skills, assisted Clayton in copying these and other letters into the journal. Among other things, this correspondence provides valuable insight into the thoughts and character of several of ’s leading citizens. ’s articulate and thoughtful letters to Carlin, for example, in which she argued against the legality of Boggs’s affidavit and the entire extradition proceedings, reveal a woman of ability and resourcefulness. Two of JS’s letters written to members of the church during this period provided important instructions regarding proxy baptisms for deceased persons and record keeping. Clayton and Snow also copied into the journal three of the early letters in a lengthy series between JS and his correspondent .
JS spent much of the last five months of 1842 in hiding to avoid arrest and extradition to . Periods of enforced solitude gave him time for sustained reflection and opportunity to commit his thoughts to paper. Lengthy recitations of the names and deeds of his loyal friends, and explicit references to his desire to have them recorded in the Book of the Law of the Lord are unique features of this part of his journal and contribute—like the lists of donations for the temple—to the unusual character of the book as a whole.
Although returned to with his family on 30 October 1842, continued keeping JS’s journal in the Book of the Law of the Lord through 20 December of that year. Clayton’s entries end with a recital of his, Richards’s, and several other men’s efforts in , Illinois, to resolve a bankruptcy case involving JS. While there, they also counseled with Judge , United States district attorney , and newly elected Illinois governor regarding the effort to extradite JS to . All three gave suggestions for how JS might safely and successfully proceed in the case against him. On 21 December 1842, the day following the party’s return to , JS appointed Richards his “private se[c]retary & historian” and Richards began keeping a new journal for JS in a small memorandum book. As temple recorder, Clayton retained possession of the Book of the Law of the Lord, in which he continued to record tithing and other donations.
Chronological Index to Journal Entries
Journal entries in the Book of the Law of the Lord were not always dated sequentially. In addition, there are several dates for which more than one entry was made, often with entries for other dates intervening. This chronological index helps to locate journal entries. In this index, sequential journal entries are not individually listed, and dates with no journal entry are not noted.
| Date | Manuscript Page | Page in JSP, J2 |
| December 1841 | 26, 31, 33, 36, 39, 43–44 | 10–21 |
| Dec. 1841 | 36 | 16 |
| 11–13 Dec. 1841 | 33 | 14–15 |
| 13 Dec. 1841 | 26, 33 | 10–11, 15–16 |
| 14 Dec. 1841 | 26 | 11 |
| 15–16 Dec. 1841 | 31 | 13–14 |
| 17 Dec. 1841 | 26 | 11 |
| 22 Dec. 1841 | 36 | 16–17 |
| 24–28 Dec. 1841 | 39 | 17–19 |
| 29–31 Dec. 1841 | 43–44 | 19–21 |
| January 1842 | 31, 43–44, 48, 56–60, 66–67 | 14, 21–32, 36–38 |
| 1 Jan. 1842 | 44 | 21 |
| 4 Jan. 1842 | 48 | 23–24 |
| 5 Jan. 1842 | 31, 44 | 14, 21 |
| 6 Jan. 1842 | 57 | 25–26 |
| 12–16 Jan. 1842 | 48 | 24 |
| 15 Jan. 1842 | 58 | 26–27 |
| 16 Jan. 1842 | 48, 58 | 24, 27 |
| 17 Jan. 1842 | 43, 56, 58 | 20–21, 24–25, 27 |
| 18–22 Jan. 1842 | 58 | 27–30 |
| 23 Jan. 1842 | 59, 66 | 30, 36–37 |
| 24 Jan. 1842 | 59 | 30 |
| 25 Jan. 1842 | 59, 66 | 30, 37 |
| 26–27 Jan. 1842 | 59 | 30–31 |
| 28 Jan. 1842 | 59, 67 | 31, 38 |
| 29–31 Jan. 1842 | 60 | 31–32 |
| February–July 1842 | 60–61, 88–95, 122–128 | 32–36, 38–80 |
| August 1842 | 128–135, 164–167, 179–184 | 80–99, 115–124 |
| 3–15 Aug. 1842 | 128–135 | 80–92 |
| 16 Aug. 1842 | 135, 164–165 | 93–96 |
| 17–21 Aug. 1842 | 165–167 | 96–99 |
| Copied Correspondence | 168–178 | 100–114 |
| 23–31 Aug. 1842 | 179–184 | 115–124 |
| September–December 1842 | 184–215 | 124–183 |
Footnotes
- [1]
One of Richards’s entries records that he was ill “& did not take notes.” Other entries, such as those dictated by JS to William Clayton while in hiding, are clearly copies of previously inscribed notes. (JS, Journal, 17 June 1842; 16 and 23 Aug. 1842.)
- [2]
Clayton, History of the Nauvoo Temple, 16; Brigham Young et al., “Baptism for the Dead,” Times and Seasons, 15 Dec. 1841, 3:626.
Clayton, William. History of the Nauvoo Temple, ca. 1845. CHL. MS 3365.
Times and Seasons. Commerce/Nauvoo, IL. Nov. 1839–Feb. 1846.
- [3]
Clayton, History of the Nauvoo Temple, 18; Clayton, Journal, 10 Feb. 1843.
Clayton, William. History of the Nauvoo Temple, ca. 1845. CHL. MS 3365.
Clayton, William. Journals, 1842–1845. CHL.
- [4]
- [5]
JS, Kirtland, OH, to William W. Phelps, [Independence, MO], 27 Nov. 1832, in JS Letterbook 1, pp. 1–2 [D&C 85:1–2, 5]; 2 Chronicles 17:9; 34:14; Nehemiah 9:3.
- [6]
See also the entry for 29 June 1842, in which Richards transferred “this Journal” to his assistant William Clayton.
- [7]
Pages 207–209, for example, contain such inscriptions. Willard Richards’s entry for 10 March 1842 also indicates contemporaneous inscription.
- [8]
- [9]
Brigham Young et al., “Baptism for the Dead,” Times and Seasons, 15 Dec. 1841, 3:626.
Times and Seasons. Commerce/Nauvoo, IL. Nov. 1839–Feb. 1846.
- [10]
JS, Journal, 8 Aug. 1842; see also Appendix 1.
- [11]
Thurs-day 30th In the A.M. spent some time with Eqr from & others in the private office and in the P.M. was in the Court martial giving testimony concerning &c.
On the 8th. of last November at about 5 o clock in the evening the Baptismal Font was dedicated. In February 1842 washed his hands in the Font being seriously affected with a Fellon, so that the Docters thought it ought to be cut open; others said it would not be well before spring. After washing in the Font his hand healed in one week.—
On the 25th. day of September 1841 a Deposite was made in the south east corner of the .—
July Saturday 2nd. Went out in the city with to look at some lots and afterwards rode out to with and others.—
Sunday 3rd. Preached at the near the on the ancient order of things &c— was at the also in the P.M.
Monday 4th. With the Legion in command all day, and at the close expressed his satisfaction with the Legion, and briefly showed the design of its organization viz to defend ourselves and families from mobs &c. He requested any stranger who was present and wished to speak to do so, when from made some friendly remarks and expressed his satisfaction; also his gratification to see the good discipline of the Legion.—
Tuesday 5th. Attended court Martial.—
Wednesday 6th. In the A.M. attending to business in the and afterwards rode out to with and others.—
Saturday 9th. Rode out on Prarie with & bro [William A.] Gheen to look out some land. Dined on his , hoed potatoes &c and in the P.M. returned after which he transacted business in the
Sunday 10th. At the stand, was some sick and could not preach. preached[.] at home in the P.M.—
Monday 11th. With in the A.M. and in the P.M. was at the reading mail papers. Bought a horse of Deputy Sheriff for au.$
Tuesday 12th. In the lodge consulting concerning s proceedings and taking affidavit. Bro’s & started for & —
Friday 15th. This A.M. early a report was in circulation that was missing. A. letter of his writing was found directed to stating to the effect that he was going away; Soon as this was known Joseph summoned the principal men of the city and workmen on the to meet at the where he ordered them to proceed immediately throughout the in search of him lest he should have laid voilent [violent] hands on himself. After considerable search had been made but to no effect a meeting was called at the where Joseph stated before the public a general outline of s conduct and especially with regard to Met again in the P.M. when & spake on the same subject after which Joseph arose and said that he would state to those present some things which he had heard respecting & being conspiring with in endeavoring to bring [p. 127]
Source Note
Source Note
Document Transcript
Document Information
Document Information
Footnotes
Footnotes
Willard Richards handwriting ends; William Clayton begins.
- [271]
While Nauvoo Legion records for this proceeding have not been located, Bennett was likely cashiered at this court-martial. The following day JS published a statement of “important facts relative to the conduct and character of Dr. John C. Bennett, . . . that the honorable part of community may be aware of his proceedings . . . as an imposter and base adulterer.” (Thomas Carlin to JS, 27 July 1842; “To the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, and to All the Honorable Part of Community,” Times and Seasons, 1 July 1842, 3:839–843.)
- [272]
The baptismal font, used for vicarious baptisms for deceased persons, was located in the basement of the unfinished Nauvoo temple.
- [273]
Nancy Alexander Tracy later recalled that “the Bible Book of Mormon doctrine and Covenants hymn book and other Church works as well as the news papers the Times and Seasons and Nauvoo Neighbor that were printed in Nauvoo and money that had been coined in that year” were deposited in the temple cornerstone. Samuel Miles left a similar account of the deposited items. The southeast cornerstone was laid 6 April 1841. (Tracy, Reminiscences and Diary, 41–43; “Recollections of the Prophet Joseph Smith,” 174; “Celebration of the Anniversary of the Church,” Times and Seasons, 15 Apr. 1841, 2:375–377; Robert B. Thompson, “Communication,” Times and Seasons, 15 Apr. 1841, 2:380–383.)
Tracy, Nancy Naomi Alexander. Reminiscences and Diary, 1896–1899. Typescript. CHL. MS 4525.
“Recollections of the Prophet Joseph Smith.” Juvenile Instructor 27, no. 6 15 Mar. 1892, 173–174.
Times and Seasons. Commerce/Nauvoo, IL. Nov. 1839–Feb. 1846.
- [274]
Wilford Woodruff recorded that JS read from Daniel 7 and “explained about the Kingdom of God set up in the last days.” Woodruff noted in his journal that about six thousand people were present, while The Wasp reported the attendees numbered “probably 8 or 10,000.” (Woodruff, Journal, 3 July 1842; “Life in Nauvoo,” The Wasp, 9 July 1842, [2].)
Woodruff, Wilford. Journals, 1833–1898. Wilford Woodruff, Journals and Papers, 1828–1898. CHL. MS 1352.
The Wasp. Nauvoo, IL. Apr. 1842–Apr. 1843.
- [275]
On 12 March 1842, the Nauvoo Legion court-martial passed an ordinance requiring the legion to hold a general parade on various days, including 4 July. (Nauvoo Legion Minute Book, 12 Mar. 1842, 12.)
- [276]
The Wasp reported that between eleven and twelve thousand people were in attendance to witness the day’s activities. (“Life in Nauvoo,” The Wasp, 9 July 1842, [2].)
The Wasp. Nauvoo, IL. Apr. 1842–Apr. 1843.
- [277]
JS’s farm.
- [278]
See Woodruff, Journal, 10 July 1842.
Woodruff, Wilford. Journals, 1833–1898. Wilford Woodruff, Journals and Papers, 1828–1898. CHL. MS 1352.
- [279]
JS’s history identifies this horse as “Jo. Duncan,” after Joseph Duncan, former governor of Illinois. Duncan served as governor from December 1834 to December 1838 and was running against Thomas Ford in 1842. Duncan was vigorously anti-Mormon in his 1842 campaign. (JS History, vol. C-1, 1356.)
- [280]
Bennett resigned as mayor on 17 May 1842 and on that date signed a statement before Justice of the Peace Daniel H. Wells that he had not observed misconduct by JS nor heard him condone sexual relations outside of marriage. Bennett later claimed he made the statement under duress. The Wells affidavit referenced in the journal entry was apparently the basis for Wells’s sworn statement ten days later, in which he declared he had seen no evidence that Bennett had testified under threat in May. (“To the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, and to All the Honorable Part of Community,” Times and Seasons, 1 July 1842, 3:840–841; “Astounding Mormon Disclosures! Letter from Gen. Bennett,” Sangamo Journal [Springfield, IL], 8 July 1842, [2]; Daniel H. Wells, Affidavit, Nauvoo, IL, 22 July 1842, Times and Seasons, 1 Aug. 1842, 3:873–874.)
Sangamo Journal. Springfield, IL. 1831–1847.
- [281]
By this time Bennett began publicly disparaging those who accused him of immoral behavior. He called on Missouri governor Thomas Reynolds to initiate extradition proceedings against JS on charges related to the Mormon War in 1838. On 12 July 1842, Miller and Derby were sent to Quincy, Illinois, and to Jefferson City, Missouri, to confer with Illinois governor Thomas Carlin and Missouri governor Reynolds, apparently to counter Bennett’s initiatives. Thirteen years later, however, Miller recalled the trip was a response to Bennett’s accusation that JS was behind the attempt to assassinate Lilburn W. Boggs. (“Astounding Mormon Disclosures! Letter from Gen. Bennett,” Sangamo Journal [Springfield, IL], 8 July 1842, [2]; Calvin A. Warren, Quincy, IL, to JS, Nauvoo, IL, 13 July 1842, JS Collection, CHL; George Miller, St. James, MI, to “Dear Brother,” 26 June 1855, Northern Islander, 16 Aug. 1855, [3]–[4]; see also JS, Journal, 24 July 1842.)
Sangamo Journal. Springfield, IL. 1831–1847.
Northern Islander. St. James, MI. 1850–1856.
- [282]
Pratt’s wife, Sarah Bates Pratt, was allegedly involved with John C. Bennett in an illicit relationship, which apparently ended quietly upon Orson Pratt’s return from a proselytizing mission to Britain in summer 1841.a When JS publicly exposed Bennett for similar relationships with other women in the 1 July 1842 issue of the Times and Seasons, Bennett asserted that JS himself seduced women in Nauvoo and that he (Bennett) was present when JS asked Sarah to be one of his “spiritual wives.” Sarah supported Bennett’s claim; indeed, that Orson was aware of the allegations against JS on 14 July (see the following letter), while Bennett’s claim was not published until 15 July, suggests that Orson first heard of it from Sarah rather than from Bennett.b JS denied the charge.c The “letter of his writing,” to which the text may refer, was written the evening of 14 July and found on Munson Street, east of Heber C. Kimball’s home; it illustrates the difficult position in which these charges and countercharges placed Orson. The unaddressed letter began: “I am a ruined man! my future prospects are blasted! the testimony upon both sides seems to be equal: the one in direct contradiction to the other—how to decide I know not neither does it matter for let it be either way my temporal happiness is gone in this world if the testimonies of my wife & others are true then I have been deceived for 12 years past—my hopes are blasted & gone as it were in a moment—my long toils & labours have been in vain. If on the other hand the other testimonies are true then my family are ruined forever.”d
(aAffidavits and Certificates, [Nauvoo, IL: 31 Aug. 1842], copy at CHL. b“To the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, and to All the Honorable Part of Community,” Times and Seasons, 1 July 1842, 3:839–842; “Further Mormon Developments!! 2d Letter from Gen. Bennett,” Sangamo Journal [Springfield, IL], 15 July 1842, [2]; JS, Journal, 29 Aug. 1842. cQuorum of the Twelve Apostles, Minutes, 20 Jan. 1843. dOrson Pratt, Letter, [Nauvoo, IL], 14 July 1842, CHL.)Sangamo Journal. Springfield, IL. 1831–1847.
Pratt, Orson. Letter, [Nauvoo, IL], 14 July 1842. CHL. MS 16976.